When I was a new teacher, I came home tired. Dead tired. My husband wanted to support me, to treat me, so he would offer to take me out to eat for dinner.
He would innocently ask, “Where would you like to go?”
Then I would despair.
Yes, dear readers, the thought of even having to choose between one of 5 choices of restaurants in our small town Overwhelmed me. First world problem, yes.
But why did I react so strongly?
An instructional day with a constant stream of choice after choice.
Choices about instruction. (We had no curriculum! Have ya been there?)
Choices about student behavior.
Choices about grading.
Choices about copying.
To copy or not to copy, that was the question.
I feel for today’s teacher even more than I emphasize with my old teacher-self. I didn’t have Google, Facebook, Pinterest, and Teachers Pay Teachers to contend with.
These platforms are dreamy in terms of possibilities. They can also feel deathly when we have too many decisions to make. Indeed, a recent study calculated that teachers have to choose among at least 205 trillion instructional options.
That, ah, could be, ah, considered challenging!
A Small Group, Guided Reading Structure to Combat Decision Fatigue
To combat decision fatigue, AND to help you accelerate all of your readers’, I propose a small group, guided reading structure that has served me well for nearly 20 years.
I’ll then describe how one teacher might use this structure to plan lessons for 2 different groups.
(Wait no more. Get your PDF copies of the 2 lesson plans I use for students at the CVC level and for those at the Advanced Phonics level. Enter your name and email below to get your copy now!)
I’ve used this structure as a tutor with hundreds of children, ages as varied as 3 to 15. It’s also similar to the structure of an early intervention called the Targeted Reading Intervention I developed at the University of North Carolina that had significant impact on all reading measures (decoding, word identification, spelling, and comprehension) as reported in these studies: (study 1, study 2, study 3, & study 4).
(This structure is generally fitting to any student at a K-3 reading level or any student of any age needing decoding, word identification, or fluency remediation.)
These are the 3 critical components of a strong, comprehensive small group guided reading session:
Re-Reading for Fluency is just like it sounds. The students re-read a book or selection of text several times until they have expanded their knowledge of high-frequency words, quickened their reading rate, and gained confidence and motivation in their reading. To help them succeed, the teacher models fluent reading while the students follow along. (We fade out this component when students are above grade level and fluent at about middle school reading levels.)
Word Work is the time for focusing on sound-based decoding and spelling for the end purpose of rapid acquisition of word identification. Here at Reading Simplified we recommend only a handful of activities that integrate multiple reading sub-skills simultaneously:
- Concept of the alphabetic principle (that our written language is a code for sounds),
- Left-to-right directionality,
- Phonemic awareness (perception of individual sounds in words, i.e., “much” = /m/ /u/ /ch/).
- Letter-sound knowledge (i.e, that “c” is usually /k/, “ow” is often /oa/, and “tch” is usually /ch/,
- Decoding strategies, such as Blending As You Read and Flex It,
- Spelling strategies, such as Say It the Way It Looks, and
- Multisyllable strategies, such as Blend As You Read by Chunk.
These reading sub-skills are integrated into just these handful of activities:
- Build It
- Switch It
- Read It
- Sort It
- Search for It
- Write It
- Flex It
(For advanced readers, Word Work can also morph to emphasize vocabulary meanings and Greek and Latin roots.)
Guided Reading is when the students take turns reading aloud a challenging text that builds their decoding and word identification skills. The teacher offers word-level support and comprehension support where necessary. Finally, students conclude the small group session summarizing what they read and preparing to work independently with their targeted sound (such as /oa/) and texts for re-reading practice.
That’s it. 🙂
The mission of this small group structure is to move ALL students to rapid acquisition of independent reading. Once kids can reading independently and enjoy reading for its own sake, then other structures may be beneficial, such as literature circles, genre study, book clubs, research studies, etc. But that’s a post for another day. Most K-3 students, as well as struggling students, however, would benefit from the above structure to efficiently advance their reading skills and enjoyment.
Thus, a teacher using this structure doesn’t have to decide what to do at the beginning, middle, and end of every 20 minute interaction with every group.
Sigh of relaxation.
Instead, she has a framework that hits the most important tasks of early literacy and adapts them to each group’s particular needs.
How One Teacher Plans Her Small Group Lessons–Group 1
Imagine a teacher. We’ll call her Ms. Peregrine. Ms. Peregrine teaches 1st grade and has 5 groups of students for her small group guided reading time. She sees 2 of these groups every day; two of these groups every other day; and the final group 1-2 times per week.
She begins making notes in her small group planner for Group #1, AKA the “gymnasts.” Based on her initial assessments of their reading achievement, they are at the Kindergarten reading level. She has placed them at the earliest CVC step and have just been exposed to short a and short i.
They have good comprehension of text read aloud to them. Her main objective is to rapidly provide them the foundation of strong decoding skills so they can learn to recognize words easily, become fluent, and learn to love to read independently.
So, on the Reading Simplified Streamlined Pathway for Kindergarten level readers, this puts them at the first CVC level.
Background: The Reading Simplified Streamlined Pathway is a kind-of scope and sequence for teaching anyone who is a young reader or a reader who is struggling. The Streamlined Pathway incorporates:
- Phonemic awareness,
- Letter-sound knowledge,
- Decoding strategies,
- High-frequency word knowledge, and
Using the Streamlined Pathway, coupled with the simple structure I’m presenting today for small group guided reading, a teacher can diagnose and plan small group and independent work more easily and with less effort.
Despite this time savings, she can also expect to see students reading achievement outcomes accelerate!
How ’bout them apples!
(Would you like to have a PDF copy of the Streamlined Pathway for K? Just enter your name and email below:)
So as Ms. Peregrine begins thinking about her lesson, she’s already grounded by the 1st CVC level–the letter-sounds, Fry high frequency words, and decoding strategies that are emphasized there. Specifically, over the course of 1-2 weeks, she will focus on these:
- Short vowels
c m p t s n h d w
- Consonant digraphs
th ch wh ll tt
Then she moves on to the specifics of her lesson:
Re-Reading for Fluency with Group 1
First, what will she select for Re-Reading for Fluency?
She just adds the name of yesterday’s Guided Reading text, “Pig Sits” by Nora Gaydos to the Re-Reading for Fluency box because she had the gymnasts group re-reading it in pairs yesterday after their time with her. Most of them should be able to read this short text fairly well to her now.
Word Work with Group 1
Second, Word Work?
A little more time to think.
Yesterday Ms. Peregrine observed that everyone was much more reliable with their knowledge of the short a sound but they were still only 50-50 with the short i sound. And, phoneme manipulation (practiced in activity Switch It) with 3-sound words was still mostly a struggle.
So, she opts for “Switch It” first and chooses a word list that targets short a and short i (the only short vowel spellings they’ve been exposed to.) But they can usually phonemically segment 3-sound words already and know essentially all consonants, so she can skip Build It from now on.
She also noted yesterday that Frank had advanced in his 3-sound word blending, but he still wasn’t independent without her coaching. The rest of the students still needed her support about 1 time during the lesson. So, Blend As You Read with CVC words should still be a goal for this group.
Thus, using the Streamlined Pathway to guide her, she writes in Read It words: has will with this.
This Read It list focuses on mostly words with continuant consonants, which are easier to blend, are on the students’ target sound needs: “i” and “th,” and are Fry high frequency words with the same vowel sound.
She won’t take the time for Write It yet either since getting them to be confident with Blend As You Read is uppermost in importance. (Also, a typical lesson with students like the gymnasts usually only includes 2 Word Work activities so sufficient time is left for Guided Reading.)
Guided Reading with Group 1
Finally, since she has already determined that blending 3-sound words and learning the short i sound are the most pressing needs of the gymnast group, Ms. Peregrine flips through her short i CVC tub of books and selects 4 copies of the “Big Hit,” by starfall.com.
Now she’s ready with a great plan for her most struggling group of readers.
Less than 5 minutes of effort to plan and…
Sigh of pleasure.
I’d be pleased to share this lesson plan structure with you for FREE right now. Please just enter your name and email below to get your own copy:
How One Teacher Plans Her Small Group Lessons–Group 2
Now our brave heroine is ready to plan for her other daily group, the Swimmers. This group tested at the early 1st grade level, so Ms. Peregrine has placed them at the second step of the 1st grade Streamlined Pathway.
- These students are familiar, but rusty, with their short vowels, and
- Their Blend As You Read strategy is developing well with CVC words.
- They know several high frequency words, too, but not all that would be expected for her school for early 1st grade.
- Comprehension of text read aloud to them is good.
(All students are sorted into 1 of 3 Streamlined Pathways: K, 1st Grade, or 2nd Grade and Up. Yes, I’ve even taught struggling high school students and an adult who was functionally illiterate with a pathway like the 2nd Grade and Up one.
By just having 3 Pathways to choose from, Ms. Peregrine minimizes The Overwhelm. These 1-pagers are a lot simpler than endless standards, basal scope and sequences, district guidelines, etc., that she used to stress over. And, yet, students learning to read quickly will be more likely to happen with this approach.
Interested in a PDF copy of the Streamlined Pathway for 1st Grade? Just enter the info below for a FREE copy:
Given that Ms. Peregrine selected Level 2 on the Streamlined Pathway, she knows she’s focusing on:
- The long o sound and its various main spellings,
o o_e ow oa oe, as well as
- High frequency words from Fry’s top 100 list that target the long o sound
go more so no
Re-Reading for Fluency with Group 2
Like with the gymnasts group, Ms. Peregrine easily chooses the Re-Reading for Fluency text from yesterday’s Guided Reading selection, “Joe and Joan.”
The swimmers just began Advanced Phonics instruction, specifically with the long o sound and its major spellings. They read “Joe and Joan” yesterday with her support and then she read it to them twice as they followed along. They also read it as partners during literacy stations. So, they should be pretty fluent at this short story by now.
Word Work for Group 2
Next up, what will she do for Word Work?
At the Advanced Phonics level, her decisions are pretty easy for planning Word Work. She aims to practice the long o sound all week, during Guided Reading as well as literacy stations, and for homework reading. Since they just got started learning the Sort It activity, it’s good to reinforce it with a new list of words.
With Sort It, she knows that they’ll be:
- Learning the various spellings of the long o sound: o o_e ow oa oe,
- Reinforcing their Blend As You Read approach to decoding,
- Practicing their phonemic awareness (especially phonemic segmentation) as they Say Each Sound As They Write Each Sound.
In addition, Ms. Peregrine is still concerned about their inconsistencies with their short vowel knowledge and their phonemic manipulation. They are pretty successful at the CVC level but she wants to challenge them with CVCC words.
So, she selects a list for Switch It that alternates several short vowels as well as moves to the CVCC level:
lamp lump limp lip lisp lip lop lot lost list last past pest pet pelt
Example of Switch It with different word list:
(Only the truly dedicated read this far. That’s you! If you haven’t snagged your copy of these lessons plans that also help you dynamically assess your student informally during instruction, now’s your time. Just enter your name and email below to get your FREE copy!)
Guided Reading for Group 2
Finally, she’s ready to select a new text for Guided Reading. She looks through her tub of long o books and selects an easier one, with less text–“Soap Boat” from starfall.com. Besides this being a good match for early 1st graders just beginning to get the concept that one sound can have multiple spellings, starfall.com also offers interactive elements to reading this book online.
She’ll send her swimmers group off to the computers to practice re-reading “Soap Boat” on their own. They’ll enjoy it and find re-reading easy.
Before that however, she’ll try to save time in their small group to also do Search for It after they read “Soap Boat.” She has paper copies of the book that each child can keep because starfall.com offers 20 texts for about a buck.
Each child will search for the long o sound in the book and circle that spelling. If time allows, they can point to where each spelling belongs on their already completed Sort It page.
Just like with Group 1, the gymnasts, Ms. Peregrine has again swiftly planned for another small group guided reading session.
Prepped and ready.
Now she has time to watch This Is Us!
Would you like to simplify your guided reading instruction, too?
Imagine if you were to plan like this. What might be the biggest benefit to you or your students? Please comment below so we can continue the conversation!